Why Traditional Productivity Advice Doesn’t Work for ADHD (And What to Do Instead)

Introduction

If you’ve ever tried to follow mainstream productivity advice—things like "just use a planner," "set SMART goals," or "stick to a routine"—you may have wondered: Why does this work for everyone else, but not me?

The truth is, that most productivity strategies are designed for neurotypical brains. They assume that:
✔ You can easily start and stop tasks when you want.
✔ Deadlines and consequences are enough motivation.
✔ Structure and self-discipline come naturally.

For people with ADHD, that’s not how our brains work.  We struggle with executive function, time management, and interest-based motivation, which means traditional methods often fall flat.  But that doesn’t mean we can’t be productive—it just means we need different strategies that work with our brains, not against them.

Why Traditional Productivity Advice Fails for ADHD

1. "Just Make a To-Do List"

The problem: To-do lists can become overwhelming, especially if they’re too long or lack clear priorities.  ADHD brains also struggle with object permanence—if the list isn’t visible, we might forget it exists.

What works instead:
✔ Keep your to-do list short (3-5 key tasks per day).
✔ Use a visual system like a whiteboard or sticky notes.
✔ Break tasks into micro-steps (e.g., instead of "write blog post," start with "brainstorm 3 ideas").

2. "Set SMART Goals"

(Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound)

The problem: ADHD brains don’t always operate in a linear way.  A rigid goal with a long deadline can feel abstract, leading to procrastination and avoidance.

What works instead:
✔ Use "Now, Soon, Later" goals to create flexibility.
✔ Build in immediate rewards to create urgency and interest.
✔ Use time-blocking to schedule short bursts of effort instead of vague deadlines.

3. "Stick to a Routine"

The problem: Traditional routines feel too restrictive and quickly fall apart if disrupted. ADHDers thrive on novelty, so rigid schedules often feel suffocating.

What works instead:
✔ Use a "menu" of tasks instead of a strict schedule. (E.g., a morning routine with flexible steps: stretch, shower, coffee, check planner—but in any order.)
✔ Plan daily "anchor points" (consistent meal times, workouts, or work sessions) while keeping the rest flexible.
✔ Allow for spontaneity and variation—switch up work locations, reward yourself with a fun task after a boring one.

4. "Use Willpower and Self-Discipline"

The problem: ADHD motivation is interest-based, not willpower-based.  If a task isn’t engaging, we physically can’t make ourselves do it, no matter how important it is.

What works instead:
✔ Gamify tasks (e.g., set a timer and race yourself, give yourself points for completing steps).
✔ Use body doubling (working alongside someone else for accountability).
✔ Create urgency by setting artificial deadlines, booking co-working sessions, or adding small consequences/rewards.

Final Thoughts

If you’ve struggled with productivity, it’s not because you’re lazy or lack discipline—it’s because the strategies you’ve been given weren’t designed for your brain.  By working with your ADHD, rather than against it, you can create systems that actually work for you.

Try experimenting with these alternative strategies and see what sticks!  And if you need support in finding what works best for you, coaching can be a great way to figure out your unique productivity style.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Late ADHD diagnosis

  Following my ADHD diagnosis a year and a half ago at the age of 52, so many things started to make sense. I had underachieved my whole life. Some of my most vivid memories from my childhood were of me catching up with school work while my friends were out playing. My parents insisted I catch up over weekends and holidays because I’d not studied when I should have done.  With the benefit of a diagnosis, I now know that my parents approached ‘the situation’ in completely the wrong way. In their defence, ADHD, which was know as Hyperkinetic Disease of Infancy in the 1970’s, wasn’t something considered to affect girls. Also, it’s now known that girls present differently to boys. Girls are more likely to be inattentive rather than behaving like the stereotypical hyperactive boy. What my parents and teachers saw was an intelligent child who wasn’t reaching her potential. I should add that my mum was an educational psychologist, and she used to regularly give my brother and myself ...
Read more

Understanding ADHD and Rejection Sensitivity Dysphoria: Navigating Emotional Turbulence

 Living with ADHD (Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder) often means grappling with a myriad of emotional and cognitive challenges. One particularly distressing aspect that many individuals with ADHD face is Rejection Sensitivity Dysphoria (RSD). This term describes the intense emotional pain triggered by the perception of rejection or criticism. Understanding the interplay between ADHD and RSD can provide valuable insights and strategies for managing these overwhelming feelings. In this blog post, we will delve into the relationship between ADHD and RSD, explore their impact on daily life, and offer practical tips for coping and thriving. What is ADHD? ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by symptoms such as inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsivity. These symptoms can vary widely in severity and often lead to difficulties in academic, occupational, and social settings. Individuals with ADHD may struggle with organization, time management, and maintaining fo...
Read more

ADHD Chronicles: When I feel like a letdown.

 We are on day five of our holiday in Turkey.  It’s just as well because it doesn’t sound as though summer is happening in the UK any time soon!  I had lots of plans for this holiday, and I am at risk of feeling as though I have let myself down.  I have attended my three ADHD coaching classes this week and done all the required preparation for them, which some people may consider going above and beyond whilst on holiday.  However, my other main plan was to write and publish two blog posts a week.  My initial goal was to blog at least weekly about what I’m learning in my ADHD coaching training, and how it is impacting on me.  I haven’t got very far with doing that yet!  That then creates a bit of a dilemma-do I go back to the beginning of my training and catch up with the backlog?  Or do I start from here, six weeks in?!  While I ponder that dilemma, I will share some of my own experiences and thoughts about ADHD.  I have definitely ...
Read more